Darcy Wells Ward wrote a fantastic post entitled “The Great Humanities Crisis.”
Ward writes, and quotes an unidentified Nussbaum:
…policy makers want to create a generation of workers, not thinkers. “The student’s freedom of mind is dangerous if what is wanted is a group of technically trained, obedient workers to carry out the plans of the elites who are aiming at foreign investment and technology investment.” (Nussbaum, 21)
The most powerful people can use their influence to create systems that engineer more serfs.
However, not all of the most powerful people always want to engineer serfs for themselves. Good intentions might guide efforts to engineer new policies.
Still, sometimes, the most difficult message to communicate is a message that says the present, current good intentions are not going to bring good outcomes.
Fear of poverty and fear of low status spur anxious parents and practical politicians and school districts to emphasize reductive skills that secure good salaries — and emphasize those salaries more than humane sensitivities and understandings born from the civilizing influence of well-taught and well-presented arts and literature.
…it is only a matter of time before the lack of interpersonal skills, as well as personal growth, created by inquiries into history, philosophy, art, music, and language will catch up with us.
Moving a society forward, like becoming an educated person, requires a balance of appreciation for traditions and appreciation for new research and theories.
Confucius once said, “Enliven the ancient and also know what is new, and then you will be a teacher.” And, you will be a citizen. And, you will be fully human.
Note: This balanced perspective won’t be accepted by certain threads of cultural conservatives, by certain threads of progressives, or by Serf Engineers.