A properly functioning mind can destroy itself. It can think itself, in a logical and rational pattern, into madness. But that’s really more about the motive than the mode. It’s not logic and rationality themselves that are the source of the problem. In that respect, my recent quotation of G.K. Chesterton might have been misleading in regards to my outlook. Chesterton wrote, “The poet only asks to get his head into the heavens. It is the logician who seeks to get the heavens into his head. And it is his head that splits.” But I don’t have anything against logicians! Promise! I have no campaign against logic or rationality. From classical Stoicism to contemporary psychological therapies like logotherapy, cognitive-behavioral therapy, and rational emotive behavior therapy, logical and rational thinking has been a sturdy pattern for healthiness. But logic and rationality also could be used in an unhealthy way. In quoting Chesterton there, my point was to identify a problem that was once explained by an evangelical psychologist, Larry Crabb. “There is an enormous difference between the joy of discovery and the passion to explain,” Crabb wrote. “The former gives life a sense of adventure. The latter makes us hate mystery.” And, I think, as Chesterton suggests, that passion to explain gets exhausting, overwhelming, and eventually, devastating. So his single metaphorical dichotomy provides me inexhaustible help: I’m not trying to get the heavens into my head; I’m just trying to get my head into the heavens. And by heavens, I’m thinking figuratively. I’m thinking about all the questions and all the data and all the good theories and all the history and all the apparent unknowns—better to sit within it all than to insist upon a perfectly systematic account for it all. The former is wonderful; the latter is exhausting. I think someone could simultaneously say discovery in any field is an amazing, exhilarating journey, and logical, rational methods help discovery on its way. Motivation makes the difference.
Help Syrian RefugeesDonate to the International Rescue Committee's efforts to assist Syrian refugees. The International Rescue Committee has a four-star rating from Charity Navigator.
donating is lovingPlease donate to help support this blog and its curious mission of faith, doubt, speculation, and wonder.
- Follow liturgical on WordPress.com
Search this site
Problem or Mystery?A problem is something which I meet, which I find completely before me, but which I can therefore lay siege to and reduce. But a mystery is something in which I am myself involved, and it can therefore only be thought of as a sphere where the distinction between what is in me and what is before me loses its meaning and initial validity. -- Gabriel Marcel
Our Ways of Understanding"Our ways of understanding have been collective, beginning with the stories that we told each other around the fire when we lived in caves. Our ways today are still collective, including literature, history, art, music, religion, and science." - Freeman Dyson
Follow on Twitter
"Referee won't blow the whistle / God is good but will he listen?" -- U2
Share & Bookmark
- "When someone opposes me, he arouses my attention, not my anger. I go to meet a man who contradicts me, who instructs me. The cause of truth should be the common cause of both." -- Montaigne
- "If your anger decreases with time, you did injustice; if it increases, you suffered injustice." -- Nassim Nicholas Taleb
- "And the missionaries, they tell us we will be left behind. / Been left behind a thousand times, a thousand times." -- Arcade Fire
Incapable of doubt, incapable of faithThe majority of mankind is lazy-minded, incurious, absorbed in vanities, and tepid in emotion, and is therefore incapable of either much doubt or much faith. -- T.S. Eliot, Introduction (1931), Pascal's "Pensees"
Wittgenstein on Kierkegaard
"Kierkegaard was by far the most profound thinker of the[nineteenth] century. Kierkegaard was a saint." - Ludwig Wittgenstein, to his friend Maurice Drury.
Read Wittgenstein and Kierkegaard: Religion, Individuality, and Philosophical Method by Charles L. Creegan free online.
- Every Day Awe: Stacy Murison on Brian Doyle November 29, 2016
- Auden Explains Poetry, Propaganda, And Reporting May 20, 2016
- Watch: Battle of the Hamlets with Benedict Cumberbatch, David Tennant, Prince Charles ETC April 25, 2016
- Poem of the Day: Yom Kippur, Taos, New Mexico September 18, 2018I’ve expanded like the swollen door in summer to fit my own dimension. Your loneliness is a letter I read and put away, a daily reminder in the cry of the magpie that I am still capable of inflicting pain at this distance. Like a painting, our talk is dense with description, half-truths, landscapes, phrases lay […]Robin Becker
- Poem of the Day: Yom Kippur, Taos, New Mexico September 18, 2018
- Poem of the Day: Rosary (Prayer One) September 18, 2018By J. Michael Martinez
- Poem of the Day: Rosary (Prayer One) September 18, 2018
- Tense and Aspect September 18, 2018[Revised entry by Friedrich Hamm and Oliver Bott on September 17, 2018. Changes to: Main text, Bibliography, notes.html] Time flies like an arrow.... Fruit flies like a banana. - Oettinger (1966) Many languages have grammatical means to indicate the time when an action or event occurs, or when a state or process holds. This phenomenon is called tense. In Eng […]Friedrich Hamm and Oliver Bott
- Hans-Georg Gadamer September 17, 2018[Revised entry by Jeff Malpas on September 17, 2018. Changes to: Main text, Bibliography] Hans-Georg Gadamer is the decisive figure in the development of twentieth century hermeneutics - almost certainly eclipsing, in terms of influence and reputation, the other leading figures, including Paul Ricoeur, and also Gianni Vattimo (Vattimo was himself one of Gada […]Jeff Malpas
- Tense and Aspect September 18, 2018
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
- Welcome mats or guarded moats? September 18, 2018Share and Enjoy: The post Welcome mats or guarded moats? appeared first on Indexed.Jessica Hagy
- Welcome mats or guarded moats? September 18, 2018
Liturgy For The PeopleThe liturgy is essentially not the religion of the cultured, but the religion of the people. If the people are rightly instructed, and the liturgy is properly carried out, they display a simple and profound understanding of it. For the people do not analyze concepts, but contemplate. The people possess that inner integrity of being which corresponds perfectly with the symbolism of the liturgical language, imagery, action and ornaments. The cultured man has first of all to accustom himself to this attitude; but to the people it has always been inconceivable that religion should express itself by abstract ideas and logical developments, and not by being and action, by imagery and ritual. --Romano Guardini, "The Awakening of the Church in the Soul"
- C.S. Lewis Drank Three Pints of Beer in The Morning -- A Letter From Tolkien
- New books: What Martin Luther thought about prayer beads
- 'The Nostalgia of the Infinite' by Giorgio de Chirico
- Harry Potter, Peter Pan, and continuity of meaning and experience
- God, Hugh Laurie, and 'House, MD'
- Conservative revolution, radical revolution: there's a difference
- A rebuttal to Hank Hanegraaff's claims about brainwashing in China in his defense of Teen Mania
- Richard Hooker versus the Puritan position -- more about the Anglican view of Scripture, Reason & Tradition
- Voltaire remained a practicing Roman Catholic to the end
- How Martin Luther's translation of the Bible influenced the German language
Arts and humansArt is the signature of man. -G.K. Chesterton
The Anguished QuestionIf you really enquire about God, not with mere curiosity, not, as it were, like a spiritual stamp collector, but as an anxious seeker, distressed in heart, anguished by the possibility that God might not exist and hence all life be vanity and one great madness -- if you ask in such a mood as the man who asks the doctor, "Tell me, will my wife live or will she die?"-- if you ask thus about God, then you know already that God exists; the anguished question bears witness that you know. -- Emil Brunner, "Our Faith"