The p.c. style of politics has one serious, possibly fatal drawback: It is exhausting. Claims of victimhood that are useful within the left-wing subculture may alienate much of America. The movement’s dour puritanism can move people to outrage, but it may prove ill suited to the hopeful mood required of mass politics. Nor does it bode well for the movement’s longevity that many of its allies are worn out. “It seems to me now that the public face of social liberalism has ceased to seem positive, joyful, human, and freeing,” confessed the progressive writer Freddie deBoer. “There are so many ways to step on a land mine now, so many terms that have become forbidden, so many attitudes that will get you cast out if you even appear to hold them. I’m far from alone in feeling that it’s typically not worth it to engage, given the risks.” — Jonathan Chait in Not a Very P.C. Thing to Say — NYMag.via Not a Very P.C. Thing to Say — NYMag.
Help Syrian Refugees
Donate to the International Rescue Committee's efforts to assist Syrian refugees. The International Rescue Committee has a four-star rating from Charity Navigator.donating is loving
Please donate to help support this blog and its curious mission of faith, doubt, speculation, and wonder.-
Join 3,972 other subscribers
- Follow liturgical on WordPress.com
Search this site
Creative Commons
For all original content:
This work by Colin Foote Burch is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.Incapable of doubt, incapable of faith
“The majority of mankind is lazy-minded, incurious, absorbed in vanities, and tepid in emotion, and is therefore incapable of either much doubt or much faith.” — T.S. Eliot, Introduction (1931), Pascal’s “Pensees”
Follow on Twitter
RSS Feeds
Share & Bookmark
Problem or Mystery?
“A problem is something which I meet, which I find completely before me, but which I can therefore lay siege to and reduce. But a mystery is something in which I am myself involved, and it can therefore only be thought of as a sphere where the distinction between what is in me and what is before me loses its meaning and initial validity.” — Gabriel Marcel
Our Ways of Understanding
"Our ways of understanding have been collective, beginning with the stories that we told each other around the fire when we lived in caves. Our ways today are still collective, including literature, history, art, music, religion, and science." - Freeman Dyson-
"Referee won't blow the whistle / God is good but will he listen?" -- U2
-
Blog: lit! Topics:Media, Liberal Arts, Humanities - "When someone opposes me, he arouses my attention, not my anger. I go to meet a man who contradicts me, who instructs me. The cause of truth should be the common cause of both." -- Montaigne
- "If your anger decreases with time, you did injustice; if it increases, you suffered injustice." -- Nassim Nicholas Taleb
- "And the missionaries, they tell us we will be left behind. / Been left behind a thousand times, a thousand times." -- Arcade Fire
-
Blog: Commerce & Arts Topics:News, Writing, Humanities Wittgenstein on Kierkegaard
"Kierkegaard was by far the most profound thinker of the[nineteenth] century. Kierkegaard was a saint." - Ludwig Wittgenstein, to his friend Maurice Drury.
Read Wittgenstein and Kierkegaard: Religion, Individuality, and Philosophical Method by Charles L. Creegan free online.LiturgicalCredoBlog
- A note about our old homepage
- Every Day Awe: Stacy Murison on Brian Doyle
- Auden Explains Poetry, Propaganda, And Reporting
- Watch: Battle of the Hamlets with Benedict Cumberbatch, David Tennant, Prince Charles ETC
- Update on the Winter Edition
- Church of the Holy Trinity, Stratford-upon-Avon, at Night
- Call for Submissions: Winter 2016 Edition
- Interview With Tara L. Masih
- The Loss of Storytelling, from Paris Review – The Art of Fiction No. 67, Paul Bowles
- While I Was In The Courtyard With The Witches of ‘Macbeth’
Poem of the Day
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Audio Poem of the Day
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Indexed
- Don’t let the bad guys get away with it.
- Blessed.
- Shocks are so much better absorbed with the knees bent.
- The world changed but their minds didn’t.
- Three cheers for birth control.
- How to avoid an existential crisis.
- Order pizza if people help you move.
- Start living in the future now.
- Self-care and self-harm can look the same.
- Debatable calculations, indeed.
Liturgy For The People
The liturgy is essentially not the religion of the cultured, but the religion of the people. If the people are rightly instructed, and the liturgy is properly carried out, they display a simple and profound understanding of it. For the people do not analyze concepts, but contemplate. The people possess that inner integrity of being which corresponds perfectly with the symbolism of the liturgical language, imagery, action and ornaments. The cultured man has first of all to accustom himself to this attitude; but to the people it has always been inconceivable that religion should express itself by abstract ideas and logical developments, and not by being and action, by imagery and ritual. --Romano Guardini, "The Awakening of the Church in the Soul"Top Posts
- New books: What Martin Luther thought about prayer beads
- Here's an Odd One: Carl Jung's Endorsement of Catholicism & Liturgical Worship For Mental Health
- Don't blame the rapist -- the rape was God's idea, after all
- The reality of pastoral gossip, or, Pastor Mark Driscoll trains you in godly leadership
- 'A Question for Pastor Lindell: What Isn’t True About Mark Driscoll?' by Warren Throckmorton
- Knowing and not knowing stuff about God
- C.S. Lewis Drank Three Pints of Beer in The Morning -- A Letter From Tolkien
- Rediscovered C.S. Lewis Christmas Sermon: 'we shall have to set about becoming true Pagans'
- God, Hugh Laurie, and 'House, MD'
Top Clicks
Tag Cloud
Bible books Christianity faith news philosophy politics quotations religionBlogroll
- Arion: A Journal of Humanities and the Classics
- Art of the Song: Creativity Radio
- BioLogos Foundation
- BustedHalo.com
- Calvinist defends the smells, bells, colors, and candles of Anglican worship
- Canterbury Tales: The Blog of Taylor Marshall
- Carnage & Culture
- Catechesis of the Good Shepherd
- Cave Wall, a journal of poetry and art
- Christian Classics Ethereal Library
- Christian Humanism: An Explanation
- Christian Humanism: Brief Excerpts
- Christians in the Arts
- Clarion Review
- Compass Direct News
- Creative Minority Report
- Creeds of Christendom
- Daily Episcopalian
- e-Catena
- ErraticImpact.com’s Philosophy Research
- Evaluating the Ezzos and ‘Growing Kids God’s Way’
- F.A.C.T.net — research on cults and abusive religion groups
- Father Stephen, Orthodox
- GodSpy
- Gregory Wolfe
- Image (art, faith, and mystery)
- Image’s blog
- In Defense of Incense [and beauty in worship]
- In Pursuit of Truth: A Journal of Christian Scholarship
- Institute for Advanced Studies in Culture
- International Cultic Studies Association
- Journal of Religion and Popular Culture
- Karl Giberson’s Web site
- Kierkegaard: free PDF download of the ‘Provocations’ anthology
- Killing the Buddha
- Korrektiv
- L’Abri Fellowship
- LiturgicalCredo.com
- Liturgy: worship that works, spirituality that connects
- Mars Hill Audio Journal
- NewAdvent.org, a Catholic encyclopedia of philosophy, theology, & church history
- NewPages.com
- Pleasant Valley Sunday
- Poetry Foundation
- Prick of the Spindle
- Project Canterbury
- reFOCUS.org
- Rev. Mark Goodman, Dean of the Cathedral Church of St. John, Albuquerque, NM (sermons on audio)
- Rev. Mark Goodman, Dean of the Cathedral Church of St. John, Albuquerque, NM, Blog from Episcopal General Convention
- Rev. Steve Wood of St. Andrew's Church in Mt. Pleasant, SC
- Seeking Spirit
- Shakespeare Association of America
- Society for Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy
- Speaking in Parables: A Study in Metaphor and Theology
- Strange Maps
- Sub Ratione Dei
- Testimonial from a Survivor: A History of the ‘Assembly of the Body of Christ’
- Testimonial from a Survivor: Life in a Dallas Cult
- The C.S. Lewis Foundation’s Weblog
- The Revealer: daily review of religion news
- The Search (The blog of Brett McCracken on film, TV, music, culture, etc.)
- The Smidgin: Thoughts from a Moderate
- Theological Book Network, Inc.
- TitusOneNine: The blog of Rev. Canon Kendall Harmon
- Vanyieck’s Last Stand
- Walker Percy resources on the Web
- WordPress.com
- WordPress.org
Meta
Arts and humans
Art is the signature of man. -G.K. ChestertonPages
Archives
The Anguished Question
If you really enquire about God, not with mere curiosity, not, as it were, like a spiritual stamp collector, but as an anxious seeker, distressed in heart, anguished by the possibility that God might not exist and hence all life be vanity and one great madness -- if you ask in such a mood as the man who asks the doctor, "Tell me, will my wife live or will she die?"-- if you ask thus about God, then you know already that God exists; the anguished question bears witness that you know. -- Emil Brunner, "Our Faith"Nota Bene
Lament for the lack of liturgical libertarians
The Pope is visiting during an election year, and that’s got me thinking about the relationship between politics and religion. A NPR reporter this morning said that the Pope and the President like each other, even though they disagree with each other on some issues, especially and most currently Iraq.
Consider that a Christian in politics will tend to err, if he’s on the right, by advocating state power for the enforcement of behavioral codes (moralistic laws); if he’s on the left, by advocating state power to force people to be compassionate with their money (tax code).
Why not have some Christians in politics who advocate freedom?
I think there’s space for Christians, especially those of the old liturgical traditions, to support libertarianism, even in this year of Obama versus McCain (OK, maybe Hillary still has a shot). Not that we can find a candidate representative of liturgical libertarianism.
Think about the ways in which New Testament teachings match up with libertarianism:
1. True morality comes from within, from a person’s character, when an individual has the opportunity to do wrong, yet chooses to do right. When someone cannot choose to do wrong, and therefore does not do wrong, that is no reflection of morality. Jesus criticized people who prided themselves on externally observable rules when their hearts were rotten. The rule-obeying was white-wash. In a related passage — and one that certainly suggests that liberty is a good thing — he condemns the Pharisess by saying, “They pile up back-breaking burdens and lay them on other men’s shoulders, yet they themselves will not raise a finger to move them.” I think of regulations, moralistic laws, and even taxes (reference Exodus 5:6-9 as an example of a state burdening people).
2. Libertarianism teaches that coercion is wrong, and the New Testament would seem to provide ample teaching for that view. In the New Testament, Paul writes that repentance comes from recognizing God’s kindness; God is not forcing people into conversion or submission. At one point in the Gospels, Jesus rebuked his disciples for wanting to call down fire on a city. Plus, we know the familiar phrases “turn the other cheek, bless those who persecute you,” etc., but how many apply that to a view of state power? (I don’t say that to nullify Thomas Aquinas’ just war theory; it seems to me that governments, from time to time, will have to use force to protect people from violent aggressors.) Consider that in terms of victimless crimes and the tax burden of imprisoning people who commit them.
Some will say, “render unto Caesar what is Caesar’s,” but can we really compare the U.S. to ancient Rome? Don’t you think the American people are supposed to be their own Caesar? “We the people,” democracy, and all that ought to de-centralize power, correct? The beneficiaries of de-centralization would be “we the people” in the U.S. For better or worse, we are Caesar. Or, maybe that’s too popular of a view. It’s probably better to say that we’re ruled by law, not by a king, and that the laws are formed within a representative democracy. We have a hand in creating our laws.
Of course, political libertarianism will be hard for many politically-active U.S. Christians to swallow, because whether they advocate state-enforced behavioral codes or state-enforced compassion, they believe the primary goal of the Christian faith is moral and ethical, so any means (including force) by which people will behave properly is good, when the actual goal of Christianity is for each individual to receive grace through faith, and then reflect grace to others.
No force involved, just freedom of conscience and freedom of expression.
-Colin Foote Burch
P.S. The Acton Institute has the right idea. Check out the Web site here.
: : : : : : : : : : :
Share this:
Comments Off on Lament for the lack of liturgical libertarians
Posted in Christian, Christianity, commentary, faith, freedom, government, law, libertarianism, religion
Tagged Christianity, commentary, faith, freedom, government, law, libertarianism, liberty, morality, news, politics, religion